Send via SMS

Friday, September 23, 2005

Million dollar playground spat
You have to wonder whether these stories are based on truth, innuendo, or something else entirely, but they do however make for interesting reading:

The stories to which I refer appeared in yesterday's UK Daily Telegraph (Magnier stallions are hit by sales ban and Breeders to bear the brunt) and have spurned a rash of comment around the world.

The original article states "A sensational bust-up between the world's two biggest owners and breeders of racehorses, Sheikh Mohammed and Coolmore boss John Magnier, is threatening to destabilise the billion-dollar bloodstock industry.

"Sheikh Mohammed has ordered his advisers to stop buying any yearlings sired by Coolmore stallions.

"The ban, confirmed to The Daily Telegraph yesterday, is also being followed by Sheikh Mohammed's brothers - Hamdan, Maktoum and Ahmed - who are all major owners and party to the decision.

The Maktoum snub came into effect 10 days ago at Keeneland Sales. Although the Maktoums splashed out some $57 million, they did not spent a cent on any yearlings sired by Coolmore stallions."

Personally I think it is a tad sensationalist to say that an entire Industry threatens to be de-stabalised as a result of two groups having a difference of opinion (if that's what it is). Coolmore stand a large number of well-performed stallions, they sell a huge number of horses to a huge number of people and whilst they have no doubt historically benefited from the Sheikh's expansive spending habits, it would be foolhardy to suggest that the company would suddenly develop cracks in its foundations if such money was no longer forthcoming. If you do claim that you may as well stand up now and say that the Industry we have only exists because of the Coolmore and Darleys of this world (then duck). People seem to be overlooking the fact that the Sheikh DID spend US$57 million at Keeneland. Some vendors would therefore appear to have done EXTREMELY well as a result of the "falling out". If he had chosen to not buy Coolmore horses AND ignore everyone else's horses as well ... then I can see cause for the words 'threatens/destabalise'.

Locally I guess it may have a few people eyeing their Giants Causeway/Rock of Gibraltar investments and feeling momentarily anxious - but the local industry is bigger than 2 people. So don't start burning the sales entry forms and weeping into your mugs of coffee just yet. As a (somewhat remote but useful) comparative example - we have been threatened with bird flu pandemics in Asia for all number of years (there was another headline on the front of the South China Morning Post yesterday actually). If you believed the press we should all have died by now (and in a rather unpleasant manner let me tell you). I finally gave up worrying about it 5 years ago.

Don't forget that fear is a very powerful tool to inflame the public - or investors -and influence prices.

Posted by: AthloneAssociates at 2:02 PM    | Permalink

Want the news as it happens?

This site offers an RSS feed.

If you don't have a RSS newsfeeder you might wish to try Pluck or FeedDemon

About Me


Katrina Partridge from Athlone & Associates authors this weblog


Awards

Search blog archives

Type in keyword

Monthly Archives


Blogroll - Thoroughbred Industry

Middle East blogs:
Dubai International Racing Carnival 2006 [Archived from 26 March 2006]

USA blogs:
Thoroughbred Bloggers Alliance
Railbird
The Pedigree Guru
Perfect Peace Farm
Avg HorsePlayer
Left at the Gate
Not to the Swift
Post Parade
Pulling Hair & Betting Horses
Tote Board Brad
Triple Crown Racing
Turf Luck
Thoroughbred Connection
Oregon Racing News
Equidaily
The Roger Stein Show
Thoroughbred Blog
Blinkers Off Blog
Horseman's Blog
The Bug Boys
The Lemon Drop Kid
Chicago Barn to Wire
Curb My Enthusiasm

Australian blogs:
Massie Lodge
Melb. Cup blog
Pedigree Dynamics

Japanese blogs:
Darkhorse Runs
Striding T'Breds in Japan

Other correspondents

Alex - Asia/Dubai

Mary - UK/Europe

Standings [USA only]

See TBA site (left column)

Copyright notice

Please note that all material on this site (including photographs) is copyright ATHLONE & ASSOCIATES LTD (2004 - 2006) and may not be reproduced in any form without prior written permission of the author.